14 June Duke-Margolis workshop + A taxonomy for non-traditional (non-Fleming) antimicrobials

Dear All: (18 June addendum: the materials from the meeting are now posted!)

First, planning continues apace for the 14 June Duke-Margolis workshop on non-traditional products. There is now a link for registration, confirmation that the event is going to be webcast, and a draft agenda. Mark your calendar now to attend either in person or via the webcast!

Second, I would like to expand a bit on my very brief 23 Apr 2018 post on the discussion of non-traditional products at the CARB-X– and GARDP-sponsored ECCMID symposium on regulatory issues. The full talk can be found here and was based on conversations with multiple colleagues (see list on slide 4). The key ideas are:

1. “Non-traditional” covers a lot of territory and it is helpful to refine the idea by envisioning a continuum for antimicrobial therapeutic products that runs from Fleming to non-Fleming products:

  • Fleming: A product that is like a penicillin in that it has the spectrum for a defined syndrome and the speed required to be suitable as standalone therapy (SSSS, if you like acronyms). Importantly, this means that standard non-inferiority trial designs can be used as the basis for registration.
  • Non-Fleming = Everything else = Non-traditional. This can include phage, antibodies, small molecules, large molecules, microbiome … it’s non-Fleming because it lacks one or more of the spectrum-syndrome-speed-standalone properties of a Fleming .

2. Digging more deeply, it then becomes helpful to replace the ambiguous terms alternative to antibioticspotentiator, and enhancer with four functional archetypes for the non-Fleming therapeutic products: Create, Transform, Enhance, and Restore:

Picture

To emphasize, this taxonomy of non-Fleming antimicrobial products is entirely functional:  physical nature of the product (large, small, phage, etc.) is not relevant! Rather, the behavior of the product defines the opportunities it brings and the challenges it faces. You should review the entire talk, but here’s a quick summary:

  • The archetypes Create and Enhance have the advantage of often being really novel, but the challenges of often being narrow, not standalone, requiring superiority study designs, and not being able to use an MIC as the basis for PK-PD thinking.
  • Conversely, the archetypes Transform and Restore have the advantages of leveraging a known component, of being able to leverage an MIC for PK-PD, and often being suitable for standalone development despite the challenge of sometimes being very narrow in terms of spectrum.

3. Agents for prevention are a distinct category and the Fleming/Non-Fleming idea is really not relevant. Instead, the problem is the general challenge of showing an advantage over best Standard of Care. See the slide deck for a specific example. 

OK, that’s enough for now … I look forward to the conversation on 14 June where we will hopefully expand further on the challenges around non-traditional products!

All best wishes, –jr

John H. Rex, MD | Chief Medical Officer, F2G Ltd. | Expert-in-Residence, Wellcome Trust. Follow me on Twitter: @JohnRex_NewAbx. See past newsletters and subscribe for the future: http://amr.solutions/blog/

Upcoming meetings of interest to the AMR community:

Share

How economists (and Finance Ministers) think…

Dear All, Anthony McDonnell and his colleagues at CGD (Center for Global Development) have just released a truly lovely paper on the economics of antibiotic resistance. What makes this one special is that the paper dissects the problem of AMR through an economist’s spectacles in a way that is very accessible to the non-expert. You

The road to UNGA 2024 is paved with … reports!

Dear All, We’re now well into the run-up to the HLM (High-Level Meeting) on AMR during UNGA 2024 (the UN General Assembly, September 2024, see the 15 Apr 2023 newsletter for details). In preparation, reports providing data to support policy and decision-making are continuing to appear. Today, for example, GCOA and IDSA released their report entitled “2024

Leaving the lab: The decline in AMR R&D professionals

Dear All, The AMR Industry Alliance has today released a fascinating and disturbing report. Entitled “Leaving the Lab: Tracking the Decline in AMR R&D Professionals” (press release, report itself), its key message of “Researchers Are Leaving the AMR Field – Even as the Threat Rapidly Grows” is illustrated vividly by the report’s graphics. I’m going

ADVANCE-ID seeks antibiotic for P2/3 development Asia!

Dear All, Yow! Led by David Paterson,  ADVANCE-ID (ADVANcing Clinical Evidence in Infectious Diseases) is a research group launched March 2023 as a network of more than 30 hospitals across Asia. The exciting news is that ADVANCE-ID have just announced that they are seeking a novel antimicrobial agent vs. MDR Gram-negatives that could be advanced in the clinic

Scroll to Top