For your weekend reading list, I have some papers on the topic of (mostly pull) incentives for antibiotics.
First, I previously wrote about the survey from TATFAR (Transatlantic Task Force on Antimicrobial Resistance) of 6 possible pull models (higher reimbursement, diagnostic confirmation, market entry rewards both fully and partially delinked, tradable exclusivity vouchers, and an options market). The final paper is now out (Ardal et al., Clin Infect Dis, 15 Oct 2017) and is definitely worth reading. You’ll also want to (re)review their prior paper (Sciaretta et al., Clin Infect Dis, 2016) on push and pull incentives.
The short summary of these papers would be that (a) we need both Push and Pull incentives and (b) there is no perfect Pull incentive but the one that seems to provide the best balance of useful effects with minimal disruption is the idea of a market entry reward that uses relatively smaller rewards to top up market-based revenues. This is also sometimes called a partially delinked market entry reward model.
Consistent with this,a new paper from Towse et al. has recently appeared in Health Policy (disclaimer — I am a co-author on this paper). Entitled “Time for a change in how new antibiotics are reimbursed: Development of an insurance framework for funding new antibiotics based on a policy of risk mitigation”, this paper compares a higher (premium) price Pull model with a partially delinked model. It concludes that:
- A premium price model has uncertain impact and risks putting commercial return and appropriate stewardship in opposition.
- An insurance model can achieve investment, reduce uncertainty for health systems, and achieve stewardship.
Third, don’t forget that DRIVE-AB is continuing to generate materials. Their July 2017 commentary to the G20 is consistent with all of the above and their final reports should start to appear soon.
Finally, IDSA’s Stakeholder Forum on Antimicrobial Resistance (http://s-far.org/; link no longer working as of March 2022) is a partnership of more than 100 health organizations seeking to ensure that any U.S. government strategy to address antimicrobial resistance involves sustained and meaningful engagement with non-government experts and stakeholders throughout the policy development and implementation process. Their website provides links to a variety of key documents on AMR.
All best wishes, –jr
John H. Rex, MD | Chief Medical Officer, F2G Ltd. | Expert-in-Residence, Wellcome Trust. Follow me on Twitter: @JohnRex_NewAbx. See past newsletters and subscribe for the future: http://amr.solutions/blog/
Upcoming meetings of interest to the AMR community:
- 29 Oct-1 Nov 2017 (Santa Fe): Keystone Symposium – Antimicrobials and Resistance: Opportunities and Challenges
- 3 Nov 2017 (no specific location): One Health Day
- 6 Nov 2017 (Boston): BAARN (Boston-Area Antimicrobial Resistance Network), Annual Meeting for 2017
- [NEW] 7 Nov 2017 (Washington, DC): FDA VRBPAC (Vaccines & Related Biologic Products) AdComm on the clinical development plan for Pfizer’s investigational Staphylococcus aureus vaccine intended for pre-surgical prophylaxis in elective orthopedic surgical population
- 7-8 Nov 2017 (Washington, DC): BARDA Industry Days
- 11-19 Nov 2017 (Annecy, France): International Course on Antibiotics and Resistance (ICARE)
- 13-19 Nov 2017 WHO’s World Antibiotic Awareness Week
- 15 Nov 2017 (London): BSAC: AMR Market Lounges. Networking day.
- 20 Nov 2017 (week of, China): UK-China Newton Fund Workshop: Antimicrobial Resistance Centre Partnerships Initiative.
- 20 Nov 2017 (London): Early Career Researcher Workshop on Diagnostics for Antimicrobial Resistance.
- 24-27 Nov 2017 (Taipei): 30th International Congress of Chemotherapy & Infection (ICC)
- 12-14 Feb 2018 (Baltimore): ASM Biothreats Conference
- 11-16 Mar 2018 (Ventura Beach): Gordon Research Conference on Antibacterial Discovery
- 21-24 Apr 2018 (Madrid): ECCMID
- 7-11 Jun 2018 (Atlanta): ASM Microbe
- 22-27 Jul 2018 (Bryant University, Smithfield, RI): Gordon Research Conference on Drug Resistance for Cancer, Infectious Disease and Agriculture